Questions Theists Can’t Answer, Nature of God (short answers)
Posted by Cory Tucholski
These questions come from an ancient-by-Internet-standards Reddit thread that compiles questions that theists supposedly can’t answer. These questions discuss the nature of God. These questions only required a few quick sentences in reply, as they are a bit puerile. Let’s dive right in:
All mainstream religions hold that God is Perfect, needing nothing, never changing.
But how could a Perfect being do anything? To do something, a motivation or decision must exist that sparks an action. Any of these things – motivation, decision, action – are all changes. To feel motivated is to desire, want or need something – and a Perfect being cannot desire, want or need or they are not Perfect. To decide anything requires a being to go from a state of having not decided to having decided. Of the two, which one would be a state of Perfection and which a state of Imperfection? To act is a matter of changing in some way. So again, at which point would such a being be Perfect versus Imperfect?
God is described as “unchanging,” or some say the fancier “immutable.” This attribute of God, however, describes only his ontology, not his agency. What this means is that God can initiate volitional changes (such as become motivated, make a decision, or perform an action) because these are matters of the will and do not fundamentally alter God’s being.
However, God couldn’t (if I can use that word without opening up a can of worms on the “omnipotence” front) make himself into a squirrel. He couldn’t initiate a change that would fundamentally alter his ontology (his make-up, his being). Which is why God can’t lie–that is an deceptive action, something which is contrary to the attributes of goodness and holiness. Also, since God is impartial and just, lying would besmirch those as well.
Why does god have no issue killing innocent people?
There are no innocent people. Everyone has transgressed the law of God. In the creation story, we find that sin (that is, a transgression of the law of God) means that we will experience death. Therefore, death is both a punishment for sin as well as a symptom of the corruption that sin introduces into a perfect world. All people deserve death.
How that death is to occur is a matter of God’s divine decree. Life isn’t a guarantee.
How can God’s forgiveness be unrestricted if we need to repent?
Forgiveness is a function of God’s mercy; he is merciful to forgive us if we repent because mercy is selective by its own nature. Otherwise it wouldn’t be mercy. God is perfectly fair to attach conditions to it.
How can God be just if we are born unequal?
All I can say is that divine justice doesn’t consider inequalities within a person or any external circumstances constraining that person to render a judgment. It considers only the relevant facts of any case, so any sort of inequality would only be considered if relevant to the eternal fate of the person so born.
I don’t have a clue what this question is getting at, so I can only offer that generic little blurb.
What need does a god have to create anything?
He doesn’t need to create anything, but he did it anyway.
I really only need to eat, sleep, and breathe. But, today I cleaned my living room from top to bottom, moving all of the furniture and using the Swiffer Wetjet behind and underneath everything. I didn’t need to do that. I watched The People’s Court and Judge Mathis. I didn’t need to do that. I drank a lot of Pepsi. I really didn’t need to that, and probably shouldn’t have. I watched the bits I missed of Tangled. Cute movie, but I didn’t need to do that. I read another chapter of Screenwriting by Syd Field. Fun and informative; I’d really like to sell a screenplay and be the next Joe Eszterhas (though I’d never write something like Showgirls or Basic Instinct; I only said that because we’re both from Ohio)–but I didn’t need to read that book, either.
What about you? Did you do anything today besides eating, sleeping, and breathing? I’m betting you did! So why is it shocking that God would do something he has no actual need to do, given that we are made in his image?
About Cory TucholskiI'm a born-again Christian, amateur apologist and philosopher, father of 3. Want to know more? Check the "About" page!
Posted on April 26, 2011, in Apologetics, God, Theology, WWGHA and tagged Divine Authority, divine decree, divine grace, divine justice, divine mercy, Nature of God, ontology, perfection. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.